Private Vasquez: Difference between revisions

From Feminist SF Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(adding some analysis)
(adding note about weaver)
Line 15: Line 15:
Female characters who were visibly muscular and strong were a rarity in commercial US film releases at the time of "[[Aliens]]" (1986); they were still rare enough five years later that Linda Hamilton's buff appearance in "[[Terminator 2]]" (1991) also excited notice.  
Female characters who were visibly muscular and strong were a rarity in commercial US film releases at the time of "[[Aliens]]" (1986); they were still rare enough five years later that Linda Hamilton's buff appearance in "[[Terminator 2]]" (1991) also excited notice.  


Vasquez is laudable in many ways: by including her, it is apparent that Sigourney Weaver's character isn't a one-off, the rare exceptional woman among men. At the least, Vasquez' character suggests that such women aren't uncommon (although still not, perhaps, commonplace).   
Vasquez is laudable in many ways: by including her, it is apparent that Sigourney Weaver's character [[Ellen Ripley]] isn't a one-off, the rare exceptional woman among men. At the least, Vasquez' character suggests that such women aren't uncommon (although still not, perhaps, commonplace).   


Coding her as physically strong or butch was at that time -- and twenty years later, still is -- also a rarity, and a welcome portrayal on the screen.
Coding her as physically strong or butch was at that time -- and twenty years later, still is -- also a rarity, and a welcome portrayal on the screen.
Line 21: Line 21:
And the presence of a Latina woman -- again, still, today, underrepresented -- was likewise welcome.
And the presence of a Latina woman -- again, still, today, underrepresented -- was likewise welcome.


However, while all these things are true, it is also true that there is some sort of disproportionate representation of kick-assery among women of color; as if it is safer (for white male creators) to confront the traditional images of femininity in a woman of color.  This pattern can also be seen in the numerous representations of [[Black Warrior Women|Black warrior women]], and it suggests that racist views of women of color -- particularly women of African descent -- affect the casting and characterization of female roles.  
However, while all these things are true, it is also true that there is some sort of disproportionate representation of kick-assery among women of color; as if it is safer (for white male creators) to confront the traditional images of femininity in a woman of color.  This pattern can also be seen in the numerous representations of [[Black Warrior Women|Black warrior women]], and it suggests that racist views of women of color -- particularly women of African descent -- affect the casting and characterization of female roles. Sigourney Weaver was butched up for this role, but not as significantly as Vasquez; as the only two adult human females in the episode, this strongly suggests some comparisons between the two.  


[[Category:Notable Female Characters|Vasquez]]
[[Category:Notable Female Characters|Vasquez]]

Revision as of 17:01, 5 February 2007

Vasquez firing a weapon. Note the arm musculature.
Vasquez in a military pose. Note the serious, unsmiling expression; women are usually told to smile; not smiling can be seen as unfeminine, or coding for butchness.

Private Vasquez was a Latina Marine in the movie Aliens (played by actor Jenette Goldstein). Vasquez was killed on the colony LV-426 in battle with the aliens.

Analysis

Unlike many women in film at that point, Vasquez was noticeably muscular. She also had one of the best lines in the film:

Hudson: Hey Vasquez, anyone ever mistake you for a man?
Vasquez: No. Anyone ever mistake you for one?

Here, the character confronts sexism with a sharp retort. It's clear from the comment made to her in this future, tough women in the marines can still occasion comment, although they are not necessarily a rarity.

Female characters who were visibly muscular and strong were a rarity in commercial US film releases at the time of "Aliens" (1986); they were still rare enough five years later that Linda Hamilton's buff appearance in "Terminator 2" (1991) also excited notice.

Vasquez is laudable in many ways: by including her, it is apparent that Sigourney Weaver's character Ellen Ripley isn't a one-off, the rare exceptional woman among men. At the least, Vasquez' character suggests that such women aren't uncommon (although still not, perhaps, commonplace).

Coding her as physically strong or butch was at that time -- and twenty years later, still is -- also a rarity, and a welcome portrayal on the screen.

And the presence of a Latina woman -- again, still, today, underrepresented -- was likewise welcome.

However, while all these things are true, it is also true that there is some sort of disproportionate representation of kick-assery among women of color; as if it is safer (for white male creators) to confront the traditional images of femininity in a woman of color. This pattern can also be seen in the numerous representations of Black warrior women, and it suggests that racist views of women of color -- particularly women of African descent -- affect the casting and characterization of female roles. Sigourney Weaver was butched up for this role, but not as significantly as Vasquez; as the only two adult human females in the episode, this strongly suggests some comparisons between the two.